## Why
The memory read-tool surface had two implementations: the app-server
extension path under `ext/memories`, and an unused `codex-memories-mcp`
workspace crate under `memories/mcp`. The MCP crate no longer has
reverse dependents, so keeping it around preserves duplicate backend,
schema, and tool code that is not part of the live app-server memory
path.
Dropping the orphaned crate makes the remaining memory crate split
clearer: `memories/read` owns read-path prompt/citation helpers,
`memories/write` owns the write pipeline, and `ext/memories` owns the
app-server extension integration.
## What changed
- Removed the `memories/mcp` crate and its Bazel/Cargo metadata.
- Removed `memories/mcp` from the Rust workspace and lockfile.
- Updated `memories/README.md` so it only lists the remaining reusable
memory crates.
## Verification
- `cargo metadata --format-version 1 --no-deps` succeeds.
## Why
Phase 2 still needs to choose the most relevant stage-1 memory outputs
by usage and recency, but exposing that ranking as the rendered
`raw_memories.md` order creates unnecessary large diff. Usage-count or
timestamp changes can reshuffle otherwise unchanged memories, making the
workspace diff noisy and giving the consolidation prompt a misleading
recency signal from file position.
This fix will reduce token consumption
## What Changed
- Keep the existing top-N Phase 2 selection ranking by `usage_count`,
`last_usage`, `source_updated_at`, and `thread_id`.
- Return the selected rows in stable ascending `thread_id` order before
syncing Phase 2 filesystem inputs.
- Update the memory README, raw memories header, and consolidation
prompt so they describe the stable order and tell the prompt to use
metadata and workspace diffs instead of file order as the recency
signal.
- Adjust the memory runtime tests to use deterministic thread IDs and
assert the stable return order separately from the ranked selection
semantics.
## Test Coverage
- Existing memory runtime tests in
`codex-rs/state/src/runtime/memories.rs` now cover the stable returned
ordering for Phase 2 inputs.
---------
Co-authored-by: Codex <noreply@openai.com>
jif-oai ·